Absolutely do not rent a car if you plan on drinking. You will end up in a jail that is quite opposite of your beautiful resort.
Explore the Riviera Maya? YES.
This is the most convenient way to get around.
Option: We use a combination of buses, colectivo vans, and taxis (instructions in our Riviera Maya map), but it's not as convenient.
Drive around Isla Mujeres? NO. The island is too small to drive around. Option: Rent a golf cart or scooter instead.
Drive around Cozumel island? YES. Hiring a taxi
for the day is expensive, and there is no bus service around the island.
Option: We rent a scooter when exploring the island.
Explore the Mayan ruins located inland? YES.
Option: You can do this using a combination of buses and taxis, but it is not as convenient.
Drive around Playa del Carmen? NO. Almost everything
in Playa's tourist area is within walking distance or a short taxi ride. Parking is difficult.
Option: Walking or taxis.
Staying in Akumal? Depends upon hotel location. Many properties are located a long distance from restaurants and attractions. Taxis are expensive.Option: Rent a bicycle or golf cart.
Staying in Tulum? NO. If you are staying along the beachfront, parking can be a hassle, and you probably won't be leaving the hotel enough to justify the expense of a car. If you are staying in downtown Tulum, restaurants are within walking distance of nearly every hotel.Option: Use taxis to travel between the beachfront and downtown.
Note: Although it's not as convenient, we prefer to use a combinaton of bus, colectivo, and taxis to get around the coastline.
You'll find bargain rentals for $20 to $30us per day available in many areas, but many of these deals are sponsored by a timeshare company—you'll have to take a tour to get the bargain price.
Most companies offer a mid-size car for $40 to $50us per day, but these offers may not include all the insurance that we recommend. This can often add another $40us to the total price (DO NOT rent a car without purchasing full-coverage insurance—more information).
Example price: We checked Aviscar rental for February 15, 2015.The fee for a mid-size Nissan car was $43us (including a $4us paperwork fee and $6us in taxes); full-coverage insurance for this vehicle was $49us, bringing the total daily price (without gas—about $20us per tank) to $98us. For $120us per day you can hire a taxi and driver to take you anywhere you'd like.
Notes: Rental from the airport will also incur an airport surcharge. You can find cheaper rental companies, but make sure that you get full-coverage insurance (see the section on rental car scams).
In Mexico, if you are involved in a personal injury accident, you will probably go to jail until things can be sorted out (even if it wasn't your fault). As a tourist (with money) the police will often side with a local driver unless the accident was overwhelmingly their fault.
If you do rent a car, absolutely get as much insurance as possible and do not count on insurance provided through your credit card. It may reimburse you later, but traffic police won't be impressed while you are sitting in the back of their car.
We prefer a taxi. If the driver has an accident, flag down a different one and continue your trip.
Parking in Cancun is nearly impossible; Playa del Carmen is not much better. . If you park illegall in Mexico, the police will not give you a ticket, they will simply remove your front license plate. You probably won't notice until you return the car and get a hefty charge for a missing plate that the company will have to track down.